Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Did I tell you I am/was going to Hawaii next month?

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Native language
    Korean
    Posts
    1,388

    Did I tell you I am/was going to Hawaii next month?

    I see the following question in a grammar exercise and don't undetstand something:

    Did I tell you that I ______ to Hawaii next month?
    A. was going
    B. am going

    I don't understand why the answer is A. I think B is more correct because of the words "next month".
    If the words were 'the following month", maybe A would be correct.

    Let's say today is Monday. I told you 2 days ago on Saturday that I will go to Hawaii 2 days later on Wed.

    Wouldn't it be correct to say:

    Did I tell you that I will go to Hawaii next month?



    Thanks all!

  2. #2
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Greece
    Native language
    British English (Sussex)
    Posts
    11,061

    Re: Did I tell you I am/was going to Hawaii next month?

    For me both are correct, though they can have different meanings.

    A Did I tell you that I was going to Hawaii next month?-Well, I've changed my mind.
    B Did I tell you that I am going to Hawaii next month? I won't be needing your services any more.

    I believe there is another thread on just this type of question.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Southwest France
    Native language
    English - England
    Posts
    24,643

    Re: Did I tell you I am/was going to Hawaii next month?

    Hello Edison,

    I'm quite happy with

    A. Did I tell you that I was going to Hawaii next month? and
    B, Did I tell you that I am going to Hawaii next month? but less so with

    C. Did I tell you that I will go to Hawaii next month? This last one is possible but the register is different (more formal) and makes the trip sound more like a royal visit than a holiday.

    Change next month to the following month and you don't alter the rules about tenses in reported speech, though you do alter the perceived time status of the sentence.

    For me all three a distinctly possible: A. is maybe the most likely. B. is fine if your plans to go are still intact. C. makes you sound as though you are a head of state, unless you are using will with its force of to be willing.

    There are a lot of issues here. There are circumstances, as Velisarius points out, where B would be used rather than A.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Native language
    Cantonese, Hong Kong
    Posts
    5,516

    Re: Did I tell you I am/was going to Hawaii next month?

    Quote Originally Posted by Thomas Tompion View Post

    C. Did I tell you that I will go to Hawaii next month? This last one is possible but the register is different (more formal) and makes the trip sound more like a royal visit than a holiday.

    C. makes you sound as though you are a head of state, unless you are using will with its force of to be willing.
    Hi, I couldn't sense the difference before your explanation. But I recall hearing people discuss attendance with future continuous tense, "I will not be joining you for dinner". Do you think

    Did I tell you that I will be going to Hawaii next month

    would reduce the formality and make the sentence come out sounding less pompous?

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    London
    Native language
    English - British
    Posts
    9,464

    Re: Did I tell you I am/was going to Hawaii next month?

    Did I tell you that I ______ to Hawaii next month?
    A. was going
    B. am going
    I don't understand why the answer is A.
    The grammar book is correct. The that-clause represents the thought in the person's mind at the time of speaking and therefore is governed by the time-context of the original statement.

    This is the traditional grammatical analysis which I maintain despite the argument of some people that the content of the that-clause should be considered outside its time-frame.

    On the traditional view, the following correct options are available:

    1(a) Have I told you that I am going to Hawaii next month? (Main verb: present perfect. Time-context: present)
    (b) Did I tell you that I was going to Hawaii next month? (Main verb: past simple. Time-context: past)

    2(a) Have I told you that I will go to Hawaii next month? (Main verb: present perfect. Time-context: present)
    (b) Did I tell you that I would go to Hawaii next month? (Main verb: past simple. Time-context: past)

    Note:
    1(a) and 2(a) imply that the plan or intention of the speaker still holds good.
    In 1(b) and 2(b), it is not implied that the plan or intention still holds good, but it is not excluded either.
    The (b) sentences allow both possibilities: (1) that the plan or intention is unchanged and (2) that the plan or intention is been changed.
    Last edited by wandle; 24th February 2013 at 12:28 PM.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •