present perfect + past time adjuncts

Discussion in 'English Only' started by Ariel Knightly, Oct 8, 2009.

  1. Ariel Knightly

    Ariel Knightly Senior Member

    Rio de Janeiro
    Brazilian Portuguese
    I'd like to know what native speakers think of the following sentence:

    We have already discussed it yesterday.

    I found it in The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language, in which Huddleston defends its grammaticality. He says that "the already indicates that I'm concerned with the occurence of the situation of our discussing it within a time-span up to now and cancels the normally excluding effect of yesterday." Who else would also produce such a sentence?
     
  2. paul_vicmar

    paul_vicmar Senior Member

    Asturias, Spain
    English, UK
    See the thread below for discussion on present perfect + yesterday. I would never say this sentence and I am sure nor would any native speaker.

    http://forum.wordreference.com/showthread.php?t=29235

    Grammatically incorrect. Yesterday is an expression of past time, which therefore cannot be used with the Present Perfect(to show some relation between the past and the present)
     
    Last edited: Oct 8, 2009
  3. Saurabh

    Saurabh Senior Member

    New Delhi City
    English-British, Hindi
    I would never say this sentence either.
     
  4. Jinsey New Member

    English-Malaysia
    Never do I say such sentence.
     

Share This Page