a cross, gold and precious stones/ apposition

Discussion in 'English Only' started by navi, Feb 15, 2010.

  1. navi Banned

    armenian
    She saw first of all a few bracelets, then two pearl necklaces, then a Venetian cross, gold and precious stones of admirable workmanship.

    Does this mean that the Venetian cross was made of gold and precious stones?
    Does the 'admirable workmanship' apply only to the 'precious stones' or both to the 'gold' and to the 'precious stones'?
     
  2. Loob

    Loob Senior Member

    English UK
    Hi navi
    Not necessarily. It could be, for example, that she saw (1) a few bracelets (2) two pearl necklaces (3) a Venetian cross (4) gold and precious stones.
    Does the context help?
    It could be either. If forced to guess, though, I'd say it applied to both.
     
  3. Yankee_NLPer Senior Member

    NE Pennsylvania
    English-USA
    This sentence is certainly ambiguous.... very hypnotic. Admirable workmanship could apply to all those... to the 'precious stones' or both to the 'gold' and to the 'precious stones'

    In hypnotic terminology this is known as sending the reader on a trans-derivational search... while the reader is confused a bit, the next sentence could hypnotically slide in under the reader's radar. Magicians call this sleight of hand, in linguistic terms this type of ambiguity is known as sleight of mouth.

    However, it doesn't mean the author intended this passage to be ambiguous. It could just be sloppy writing.
     

Share This Page

Loading...