About the usage of a comma and a period.

[cosmicbelt]

Which is the best?
A: I am deeply impressed with the beauty of the universe, the big scale galaxies and the beautiful scenery.
B: I am deeply impressed with the beauty of the universe. The big scale galaxies and the beautiful scenery.
C: I am deeply impressed with the beauty of the universe. The big scale galaxies and the beautiful scenery!

 

[grassy]

What do you think?

 

[cosmicbelt]

What do you think?

I think A is the best and C is also good. Is it all right?

 

[Andygc]

There's no "best". B and C are just wrong. "The big scale galaxies and the beautiful scenery." is not a sentence.

 

[grassy]

I think A is the best and C is also good. Is it all right?

I agree about A. I understand that you want C to work as an exclamatory sentence, but there's something off about it.

 

[Andygc]

A is odd because it appears to be a list, but that says

I am deeply impressed with:
1. the beauty of the universe
2. the big scale galaxies, and
3. the beautiful scenery.

Perhaps:
I am deeply impressed with the beauty of the universe: its big scale galaxies and beautiful scenery!

But I find it odd to talk about "beautiful scenery" in that context.

 

[cosmicbelt]

There's no "best". B and C are just wrong. "The big scale galaxies and the beautiful scenery." is not a sentence.

Your opinions are useful. Thank you.

 

[cosmicbelt]

I agree about A. I understand that you want C to work as an exclamatory sentence, but there's something off about it.

Thank you very much.

 

[cosmicbelt]

A is odd because it appears to be a list, but that says

I am deeply impressed with:
1. the beauty of the universe
2. the big scale galaxies, and
3. the beautiful scenery.

Perhaps:
I am deeply impressed with the beauty of the universe: its big scale galaxies and beautiful scenery!

But I find it odd to talk about "beautiful scenery" in that context.

I appreciate that you taught me subtlety and details of English.