for which they get

daruk

Senior Member
Korean
Hello, forum gurus!

A.
But if you had to hire people of the same caliber they would cost you an arm and a leg. Rather, people in these communities are happy to give their time to society at large (for which they get the same social benefits we all get from helping a friend paint a room). What can we learn from this that is applicable to the business world?

B.
But if you had to hire people of the same caliber they would cost you an arm and a leg. Rather, people in these communities are happy to give their time to society at large, for which they get the same social benefits we all get from helping a friend paint a room. What can we learn from this that is applicable to the business world?


― Dan Ariely, Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions

*** A and B are same, except that the ( ) is used or not.


1. What does the which refer to, in A and B?
their time? or to give their time to society at large

2. How about if for which is replaced with from which?


Many thanks, dear English gurus, in advance.
Partial explanations would also be greatly appreciated.
 
Last edited:
  • LVRBC

    Senior Member
    English-US, standard and medical
    The "which" refers to the experience of volunteering their time, presumably. "From which" seems an acceptable substitution in this context. (It's not particularly well written, as far as one can tell from this tiny excerpt. "To give their time to society at large" is a weird phrase conceptually, though it is grammatically acceptable.)
     

    daruk

    Senior Member
    Korean
    The "which" refers to the experience of volunteering their time, presumably. "From which" seems an acceptable substitution in this context. (It's not particularly well written, as far as one can tell from this tiny excerpt. "To give their time to society at large" is a weird phrase conceptually, though it is grammatically acceptable.)

    I see.
    This helps.
    Thank you so much!
     
    Top