no use phoning him; hes gone away [Semicolon vs comma]

< Previous | Next >

Blacksheep846

Member
Lithuanian
Hello,

''It's no use phoning him; hes gone away.''

''Give it back, it's mine.''

What kind of use of the semicolon and comma is in the sentences above?

Thank you in advance.
 
  • lingobingo

    Senior Member
    English - England
    The use of the semicolon is what's known as a "vexed question". In other words, people disagree about it!

    You do quite often find one statement written in a sentence, after which only a comma is added before another statement is introduced which could equally well have been written as a separate sentence. That's the case in both of your examples. Either of them could have used a comma, or a semicolon, or a full stop/period. In my view it's mainly a matter of personal choice.

    Where semicolons are particularly useful is in a list of items in a sentence, in which some of those items are themselves subdivided by commas. In such a case, semicolons between the main items are very useful for clarity.
     
    < Previous | Next >
    Top