Possessive - <minutes, minutes'> drive/ walk/ journey
- Thread starter mimi2
- Start date
Oh Mimi - you are testing the native English speakers today!
Yes, your sentence is grammatically correct because it's a drive of only a few minutes. You could avoid the apostrophe by saying "By car, the temple is only a few minutes away from the station".
Yes, your sentence is grammatically correct because it's a drive of only a few minutes. You could avoid the apostrophe by saying "By car, the temple is only a few minutes away from the station".
Mimi's choice appears 100% logical to me, and I would defend it grammatically and logically. But I believe it is usually written this way:Tresley said:
"a few minutes drive"
It is a shame that Google ignores certain characters. If you do a search for "a few minutes' drive", you will also get results for "a few minutes drive". You might wish to check for yourself which looks better. As we all know, the fact that something is more common in a Google search does not make it right.
Gaer
I believe that "a few minutes' drive" should include the apostrophe.
Edited to add: from what I've just read, it is an example of the genitive form. This works like the possessive, because the phrase may be written "a drive of a few minutes" but those few minutes don't actually "possess" the drive.
Edited to add: from what I've just read, it is an example of the genitive form. This works like the possessive, because the phrase may be written "a drive of a few minutes" but those few minutes don't actually "possess" the drive.
rsweet said:
Is it, really? Perhaps that's a different question....
I don't like the apostrophe. The phrase a "few minutes drive" is somewhat casual in tone, and even if the apostrophe could be justified by rules and/or an appeal to the genitive, it seems unnecessary.
Strange to say, because we are talking about a written form, but the apostrophe seems wrong to my ear, which would not know if the apostrophe was there or not! And I imagine that's because the phrase is usually spoken, or, if written, the writing is supposed to seem as casual as ordinary speech.
Logically "a day's work" and "a few minutes' drive" are correct, so I don't think anyone could argue with either one.rsweet said:
However, it is always interesting to note that usage in English often defies rules, so before deciding what is "correct" and "incorrect" it helps to analyze (take careful note) of how such phrases are written by writers who(m) you admire.
"A few minutes drive", with no possessive mark, is obviously much more common. However, "for my wife and I" is about twice as common as "for my wife and me", and in this case I think almost all people would immediately agree that "for my wife and I" is simply wrong.
Gaer
Hi,
I read a sentence:
"I like the neighbourhood. It's very quiet, and only about fifteen minutes' walk to school."
Does it really need a apostrophe after minutes?
Thanks!
I read a sentence:
"I like the neighbourhood. It's very quiet, and only about fifteen minutes' walk to school."
Does it really need a apostrophe after minutes?
Thanks!
I do enjoy the opportunity to argue with the mighty Panj
on matters gramatical.In the above sentence the ten minutes reference is a descriptive.
The walk is being described as being of ten minutes duration.
I don't think that a descriptive can be a possessive.
.,,
I do enjoy the opportunity to argue with the mighty Panj
In the above sentence the ten minutes reference is a descriptive.
The walk is being described as being of ten minutes duration.
I don't think that a descriptive can be a possessive.
.,,
How dare you challenge the great Panj. He's right. The great Panj is always right. the descriptive form is, "a ten minute walk"
It is the same with "three day's march" and "a week's supply of food." What is the "s" doing on the end of the word "week" if it is not indicating the possessive case.
I look forward to a long debate on this subject.
I am adding this thread to the previous thread on the same topic.
And please note that the views I expressed are drawn from these sources.
In this particular construction, the ten minutes takes on a possessive form.
It is a ten-minute walk to the river.
It is ten minutes' walk to the river.
It's all in a day's work.
And please note that the views I expressed are drawn from these sources.
In this particular construction, the ten minutes takes on a possessive form.
It is a ten-minute walk to the river.
It is ten minutes' walk to the river.
It's all in a day's work.
I just saw a recent thread, closed due to similarity with this one, that asked which of these is correct:
"a 10-hour trip v. 10 hours' trip
a 10-day vacation v. 10 days' vacation
eight-hour sleep v. eight hours' sleep
a one-hour pay v. an hour's pay"
Most of the answer is already here, but I would like to add a little to it and invite discussion as appropriate. As I see it:
"A 10-hour trip" is fine. The article a modifies "10-hour trip", a count-noun phrase. "10 hours' trip" sounds odd because trip is a count noun.
"A 10-day vacation" is fine, and so is "10 days' vacation", because vacation can be either count or noncount.
"Eight hours' sleep" is fine, but "eight-hour sleep" requires a determiner such as an: "an eight-hour sleep". Sleep can also be either count or noncount.
"A one-hour pay" sounds odd to me, but "an hour's pay" is fine because pay is noncount and an = "one" modifies hour, not pay.
Similarly, "a few hours' pay" is valid too because "a few" modifies hours, not pay. And "a few weeks' wages" is also valid.
"a 10-hour trip v. 10 hours' trip
a 10-day vacation v. 10 days' vacation
eight-hour sleep v. eight hours' sleep
a one-hour pay v. an hour's pay"
Most of the answer is already here, but I would like to add a little to it and invite discussion as appropriate. As I see it:
"A 10-hour trip" is fine. The article a modifies "10-hour trip", a count-noun phrase. "10 hours' trip" sounds odd because trip is a count noun.
"A 10-day vacation" is fine, and so is "10 days' vacation", because vacation can be either count or noncount.
"Eight hours' sleep" is fine, but "eight-hour sleep" requires a determiner such as an: "an eight-hour sleep". Sleep can also be either count or noncount.
"A one-hour pay" sounds odd to me, but "an hour's pay" is fine because pay is noncount and an = "one" modifies hour, not pay.
Similarly, "a few hours' pay" is valid too because "a few" modifies hours, not pay. And "a few weeks' wages" is also valid.
A note on the origin of this.
A ten minutes' walk appears thus because it is, grammatically, the genitive case. In Old English, this was most often indicated by an -s ending. Since you can say, a walk of ten minutes, there is no case indication, but the "possessiveness" is an older morphological remnant.
A ten minutes' walk appears thus because it is, grammatically, the genitive case. In Old English, this was most often indicated by an -s ending. Since you can say, a walk of ten minutes, there is no case indication, but the "possessiveness" is an older morphological remnant.
Hi,
Just another little question if you don't mind! ^_^
Does it mean that the article -a drops the plural (minutes)? Is it wrong to say "a ten minute's walk"?
Many thanks.
bw
Just another little question if you don't mind! ^_^
Does it mean that the article -a drops the plural (minutes)? Is it wrong to say "a ten minute's walk"?
Many thanks.
bw
Last edited by a moderator:
Note that the plural ending -s applies to one noun only. For example, the plural form of "secretary of state" is "secretaries of state".
However, the "possessive" -'s or -' governs an entire noun phrase, as if it were a postposition:
The Secretary of State's car = The car of the Secretary of State.
I saw you-know-who's son today = I saw the son of you-know-who today.
Ten minutes' walk = A walk of ten minutes.
A phrase used as an attribute in front of a noun usually does not show number, even if the same phrase after the noun does:
A ten-minute walk = A ten-minute-long walk = A walk ten minutes long = A walk ten minutes in length.
Such a phrase requires hyphens if it contains an adjective followed by a noun. Both the hyphen(s) and the lack of plurality help to indicate the extent of the attributive phrase.
However, the "possessive" -'s or -' governs an entire noun phrase, as if it were a postposition:
The Secretary of State's car = The car of the Secretary of State.
I saw you-know-who's son today = I saw the son of you-know-who today.
Ten minutes' walk = A walk of ten minutes.
A phrase used as an attribute in front of a noun usually does not show number, even if the same phrase after the noun does:
A ten-minute walk = A ten-minute-long walk = A walk ten minutes long = A walk ten minutes in length.
Such a phrase requires hyphens if it contains an adjective followed by a noun. Both the hyphen(s) and the lack of plurality help to indicate the extent of the attributive phrase.
Last edited:
Thank you so much you both blueg. and forero!
Your remarks were extremely helpful.
bw
Your remarks were extremely helpful.
bw