My book says 一點兒 ("a little") is transliterated yìdiǎnr in Pinyin. I have heard several speakers pronounce this word and cannot detect any hint of "n". It sounds as if it were yìdiǎr. Can anybody help me?
Pronunciation: 一点儿(點兒)
- Thread starter James Bates
- Start date
Oh, I see. I guess it depends on the dialect.
謝謝!
謝謝!
"dianr" means the er-ization of "dian". It does not represent the actual sound.
I think OP's question is if the nasal sound is dropped. That's true. There is no way to er-ize /n/.
I think what column4 means is that you can't use Pinyin "diar" to represent the "correct" sound of "dianr". In fact, "dianr" sounds more like "dier", while "diar" means a different sound to native speakers. ("dier" is also incorrect because it represents a third sound actually. The only correct way to write that sound is "dianr".)
I think OP's question is if the nasal sound is dropped. That's true. There is no way to er-ize /n/.
I think what column4 means is that you can't use Pinyin "diar" to represent the "correct" sound of "dianr". In fact, "dianr" sounds more like "dier", while "diar" means a different sound to native speakers. ("dier" is also incorrect because it represents a third sound actually. The only correct way to write that sound is "dianr".)
Last edited:
For me, there are mainly two classes of r-colored vowels: er and ar. And I oftten pronounce “er” the same as “ar”.
dianr, dier and diar are exactly the same to me.
xinr(笔芯儿) and jianr(打尖儿) may be pronounced either the same or differently.
When there's an "n" sound at the end of a Chinese vowel, your tongue doesn't need to touch the roof of your mouth, not like in English.
So there isn't such a possibility for a "nr" sound in Chinese, it can't be pronounced. It's just a mark.
Another example, when a Chinese pronounce 天安门 "Tian-an-men", it won't become "tian-nan-men".
So there isn't such a possibility for a "nr" sound in Chinese, it can't be pronounced. It's just a mark.
Another example, when a Chinese pronounce 天安门 "Tian-an-men", it won't become "tian-nan-men".
Do you mean it's the widely accepted way to pronounce (as you say In fact, "dianr" sounds more like "dier", while "diar" means a different sound to native speakers), or you mean it's your own way?
It's still not clear to me.
北京话儿化韵的社会分歧(http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-781460-616696.html) 沈炯(He was a professor of Peking university)
According to him, “ianr” and “ar” are the same (for most speakers).
/ɐʳ/ and /ɚ/=/əʳ/ in his paper are the two kinds of r-vowels I said.
As for ie and üe, they are /ieʳ/ and /yeʳ/ according to the table at the last paragraph.
eir is /ɚ/ according to the same table. However, he said eir is /eʳ/ somewhere else.
According to his research, ier and ir has a high merging rate. 爷儿 = 姨儿(27.7~41.9%), 叶儿 = 意儿(48.16~67.21%)
It's very obvious to me that these 3 sounds are different. I was not saying dianr is similar to dier. I was only trying to explain the notations: dianr sounds like d-i-er(得衣而), but if I see "dier", I will take it as die.r (er-ize of 碟, which is a different sound). I talked about notations because of colum4's post (that may confuse OP whose main concern is if 'n' is dropped.)
As for the combination of dianr and diar, that's a different topic. No matter how it is actually pronounced, I believe everyone can still distinguish the sounds. Moreover, I've been speaking the language since born but never heard of dianr and diar are merged. I won't understand if people speak in that way. Beijing is not the only place to use 儿化音. I don't think these sounds have been merged in other places or in the standard 普通话. Imagine in 新闻联播, the 播音员 says "...一嗲儿...", they must have problems with their tougue
Last edited:
As a Beijinger, I can't find any difference between "dianr" and "diar". 颠儿 and 嗲儿 are completely the same to me (except their tones).
And I can hardly imagine how can anyone distinguish these two, not even the reporters.
There isn't any formal word using the Pinyin of diar, 一嗲儿 is not even a word. I don't think I can hear 新闻联播 says diar. 一点儿 is the only possibility.
In my opinion, ar and er can be distinguished easily, but ar and anr are exactly the same.
Also er and enr and eir are the same, e.g. 奔儿(benr), 辈儿(beir), all pronounced er sound.
Last edited:
Hi James Bates,
there's no way to pronounce the retroflex 'r' in English without at least a hint of nasality (Scotsmen not included), and the same goes for those Chinese dialects that also have it.
So, whether you represent the nasal sound by writing an 'n' or not, it makes no difference to the humming sound that escapes through your nose.
there's no way to pronounce the retroflex 'r' in English without at least a hint of nasality (Scotsmen not included), and the same goes for those Chinese dialects that also have it.
So, whether you represent the nasal sound by writing an 'n' or not, it makes no difference to the humming sound that escapes through your nose.
Thanks a lot. That makes sense
I think I understand the problem now. Do you pronounce 面嘎儿嘎儿 as 面肝儿肝儿 (i.e. ar is pronounced as 而)? That's the only "reasonable" sound that I can imagine, and that's a very typical Beijing "taste" to me. In places other than Beijing, we do distinguish ar and anr. The first one is like American sound of the letter 'R' but the second is like '而'.
Last edited:
To be honest, as a non-Beijinger (originally from Shanxi), I don't think I can differentiate dianr and diar either. There might be a slight difference when I actually say them (maybe a is more nasalized in dianr), but I don't make the distinction consistently. Although 'dier' remains distinctive from those two. Similarly, eir and enr are of the same situation to me.
I agree. The difference is psychological: if you think there is a difference, you WILL hear the difference
Yes. Although I don't know what are those, I would pronounce 嘎儿 as 肝儿. I prefer omitting the "n" sound when adding the "r" sound.
However, I would pronounce 而 as er(鹅儿) but not ar(啊儿). To me, the Pinyin sound a(啊) and e(鹅) are clearly different. Only the ending parts are debateable. We'll discuss this in the other post.
Last edited:
In my audio lessons, there is no pronunciation of the "n" whatsoever for "yīdiǎnr". I am wondering if that is correct. Thanks!
Thank you! 谢谢！
Since we can't pronoun "nr" anyway...
This problem has just been discussed on this forum recently.
This problem has just been discussed on this forum recently.