Punctuation

[Jana337]

Swoją drogą te podobne artykuły x które przeczytałeś nie były przypadkiem też gdzieś zamieszczone?
(...) jeśli zamieszczasz bibliografię x z której korzystałeś przy robieniu pracy x to nie podajesz adresu biblioteki x z której je wypożyczałeś, tylko dane książek x które wypożyczyłeś Source

My Czech eyes miss a couple of commas in the sentences (marked with x). Is Polish different?

Jana

 

[ChillingSilences]

The only place I might add a comma is "...przy robieniu pracy, to nie podajesz adresu..."
Everywhere else though, you really don't need commas.
You don't usually put commas before "które", which is where almost all your X's are.
Hope that helps.

 

[Jana337]

The only place I might add a comma is "...przy robieniu pracy, to nie podajesz adresu..."
Everywhere else though, you really don't need commas.
You don't usually put commas before "które", which is where almost all your X's are.
Hope that helps.

Interesting. I kind of thought that all Slavic languages were similar punctuationwise. I believe the Czech way makes texts much better structure and easier to skim.

Thanks,

Jana

 

[Thomas1]

Albeit punctuation is not my strong point , I could swear I heard of a rule that you have to put a coma before który, maybe not in all cases but there are some when doing so is oblagatory (I'll try to let you know when I recall when).
However, to make the situation even more complicated ; in the above excerpt I'd also add a comma in the same place where ChillingSilences would insert his.

 

[mikesz14]

moim zdaniem jana wstawila prawie wszytkie przecinki dobrze.

"..., które przeczytałeś, ..." to jest chyba zdanie wtracone wiec oddzielamy dwoma przecinkami :/

 

[ChillingSilences]

I guess I was wrong with the commas... I don't really know the punctuation rules in Polish, and was just going with what sounded right to me =) Sorry.

Anyway, about "więc", it means "so" (like Thomas1 said), not "also" (like mikesz14 said). This, I am completely sure about!