Three years ago I was to/in Germany on a cultural exchange.

Discussion in 'English Only' started by roxanelag, Feb 11, 2019 at 11:55 AM.

  1. roxanelag Senior Member

    Hi everyone, how's it going?
    I am studying for my C2 exam (future C2 exam), and I've come across this sentence in an exercise:
    - Three years ago I have been to Germany on a cultural exchange.
    I correct the tense 'Three years ago I was to Germany...' and that's it. However, shouldn't the preposition 'to' change into 'in': ... I was in Germany?
    Talking about my current location, I would say, 'I am in Spain, at the moment.' Am I right here?

    Can you help me out with this question?

    Thanks in advance.
    Have a great day!
  2. entangledbank

    entangledbank Senior Member

    English - South-East England
    Yes, when it means "go (have gone)", it can only be perfect "have been": I have been to Germany. You can't say :cross:I was to Germany. But when it contains a time phrase, you can't use perfect, so yes, it needs to be 'in', and it doesn't mean "went to", it means simply "was in".
  3. lingobingo

    lingobingo Senior Member

    English - England
    “I was to” is wrong, because the verb “to be” is a linking/stative verb (denoting a status, not an action) and therefore does not fit with the preposition “to”, which suggests movement so is usually preceded by a dynamic verb, such as “go”.

    I went to Germany :tick: / I was in Germany :tick:

    I was to Germany :cross: / I went in Germany :cross:
  4. Loob

    Loob Senior Member

    English UK
    Hi roxanelag

    I think the exercise-setter expected you to change "I have been" to "I went" rather than "I was". That way, you could leave the preposition unchanged:).
  5. kentix

    kentix Senior Member

    English - U.S.
  6. roxanelag Senior Member

    You are right, and I'm feeling a bit stupid now.
    It's quite easy to make a stupid mistake when you are not completely focus on what you are doing.
    Thanks to you all for your time and great explanations.
    Have a great day.
    P.s: I'm off to whip my back in penitence for this... sin.
  7. roxanelag Senior Member

    Thanks a lot, lingobingo.
  8. roxanelag Senior Member

    Thanks Entangledbank. Let's see if a coffee perks me up and this doesn't happen again.
  9. kentix

    kentix Senior Member

    English - U.S.
    I'm off to whip my back in penitence penance for this... sin.

    And a little extra whipping.:);)
  10. roxanelag Senior Member

    Haha! Another mistake! No more English for today. ;)
    Haha! What a Monday?
    That 'penance' is written down, Kentix.
    I appreciate your help. :)
    Have a nice one
  11. kentix

    kentix Senior Member

    English - U.S.
    I messed up, too. I tried to say "Add a little whipping." but I think autocorrect got me.
  12. Chasint Senior Member

    English - England
    With whipping cream?

    Whipping cream recipes - BBC Food
  13. roxanelag Senior Member

    I know it is off topic, but very often I wonder whether this autocorrect function doesn't make our brains lazy creatures.
    Thanks Kentix.
    Also off topic, but I got mouth-watering :D

    Thanks a lot for your answers (and suggestions;))
    Have a good one.

Share This Page