Hello. I was watching an interview with Beyonce. The interviewer asked her "how would your mom have handled you and your sisters if you had been in a car arguing"? " and she replied" I was thinking about it I was watching it... My mother'd definitely RAN away and she'd definitely told me Holla " why ran not would've run? Is it OK in speech?
Would + simple past verb
- Thread starter Poland91pl
- Start date
"I was thinking about it I was watching it... My mother'd definitely RAN away and she'd definitely told me Holla" doesn't make a lot of sense without more context, but the use of "ran" rather than "run" is probably just the kind of error we make when we're talking a bit faster than we can think.
Just asking because I've heard it many times in song. Phrases like ' I Would've saw " for instance.It is a common mistake to use have/had ran, even among native English-speakers, Poland91pl. I don't recommend that you copy it. Use have/had run.
cross-posted with The Newt.
Don't expect good grammar from songs. Rhyme, Rhythm and vernacular idiom are far more important than grammar - or even sense.
so you make the same mistake? and say " would've ran "?It is a common mistake to use have/had ran
cross-posted with The Newt.
and why did she say" my mom would definitely ran away" and not "my mom would have definitely run away"
?
the question was " how would your mom have handled you...?"
?
the question was " how would your mom have handled you...?"
No. Like just about everybody, I occasionally make mistakes when I speak. But using have ran isn't one of them.